Obj. ID: 53633
Modern Jewish Art Monument to Jewish victims of the Holocaust in Providence, RI, USA, 1993
Name of Monument
No official name
What/Who is commemorated
Jewish victims of the Holocaust
Description
The Memorial consists of a paved and gated area behind the Jewish Community Center. A 12-foot-tall steel and bronze memorial sculpture by artist Barney Zeitz stands in the center of a concrete courtyard, the center of which – under the sculpture – is paved with triangular granite tiles forming a large Magen David. Seasonal plantings are on ??? sides of the space, which allow it to be defined as a "Memorial Garden.". Entrance to the space is from the area of the parking through a metal gate. The second entrance is from the lower level of the JCC.
On entering the gate, one faces a blank wall and must turn abruptly to either side to continue down ramps into the central memorial space. This arrangement is meant to recall the process of selections by Jews suffered upon arriving at some concentration camps. The enclosed space conveys as meant to sense of confinement symbolic of the situation faced by the Jews of Europe.
On the wall facing the central monument is written in Hebrew "עם ישראל חי" and in English letters Am Israel Cha (translation: The People of Israel Live).
The monument rises from a flat black steel Star of David set in the middle of the courtyard. Six black steel bars or legs rise from the star. Attached to each leg several feet above ground, is a piece of steel. To these are attached (and seem to hang) four reddish bronze panels, whose vaguely triangular shapes suggest wings or flames. The bronze was treated with a dark protective chemical agent. On these six metal plates are inscribed Hebrew and English inscriptions, and on each of the six, the yellow outline of a single Jewish Star. Names of concentration camps are given, together with a quotation from Ezekiel in Hebrew and English.
Clustered above the shields, tapering to a narrow juncture, are symbols reminiscent of ram's horns (shofars). After tapering as it rises, the monument flares out near the top. The forms suggest flames, or more optimistically the petals of a flower, or perhaps hands clasped in supplication.
Inscriptions
On the wall, in Hebrew and transliterated Hebrew:
“עם ישראל חי"
Am Yisrael Chay
Translation: The People of Israel Live
On sculpture “wings”:
In Hebrew and transliterated Hebrew:
REMEMBER זכור
In English:
FOR THE DEAD AND THE LIVING, WE MUST BEAR WITNESS
Hebrew with mistakes, Ezekiel 37:12:
כה אמר אדני יהוה הנה אני כתח [פתח] את קברוהיכם [קברותיכם] והעליתי אתכם מקברוהיכם [מקברותיכם] עמי והבאתי אתכם אל אדמת ישראל
English:
- AUSCHWITZ - MAIDANEK – BUSCHENWALD -
THUS SAID THE LORD GOD: BEHOLD, I WILL OPEN YOUR GRAVES AND CAUSE YOU TO COME UP OUT OF YOUR GRAVES O MY PEOPLE AND I WILL BRING YOU INTO THE LAND OF ISRAEL
TREBLINKA – BERGEN BELSEN – DACHAU
MAUTHAUSEN – WARSAW – SOBIBOR
CHELMNO – BABI YAR - FLOSSENBURG
THERESIENSTADT - BELZEC - VILNO
Commissioned by
The Rhode Island Holocaust Survivors
City of Providence (funding)
sub-set tree:
| Dwares Jewish Community Center 401 Elmgrove Ave
Forged and welded steel (sculpture)
Bronze (sculpture)
Courtyard dimensions approximately 60 x 60 feet (18.28 meters 18.28 meters)
The memorial monument took more than 12 years to plan and create, due to organizational and financial difficulties. Survivors approached Mayor Cianci in the early 1980s requesting city support. The mayor pledged $36,000, but funds were not available, and only during a subsequent term in office was the pledge honored. In May 1988 the Rhode Island Holocaust Memorial Museum, located at the JCC, was dedicated. A committee then commissioned sculptor Barney Zeitz to create a memorial sculpture which was dedicated on Kristallnacht, November 9, 1993. The sculpture was the center of the Providence community’s Yom ha-Shoah annual commemoration for many years.
This design for the outdoor, abstract steel and bronze sculpture by artist Barney Zeitz was unanimously chosen by members of three organizations. The City of Providence contributed $36,000 toward the design, selection, and creation of the sculpture.
In a forceful speech at the monument dedication Holocaust survivor Morris Gastfreund emphasized that:
Everyone knew - the Pentagon knew, the State Department knew, and the White House knew. Most governments knew; only we, the victims in the pit of hell, did not know.
Therefore, the bystanders share almost the same guilt as the perpetrators of the crime. These acts of indifference to genocide will be a blood stain on humanity forever.
In this solemn hour in which we dedicate a monument in memory of our 6 million dead, we must pay tribute to the righteous gentiles of some nations, who - although in a very small minority - put their lives in jeopardy and in some cases sacrificed their lives to help the Jewish people.
We must, however, remember with sorrow the collaborators of most European countries who voluntarily helped the Nazis accomplish their murderous task …
Fortunately, there are some people who see the danger in renewed anti-Semitism, racism and bigotry. Today's honored guest, Mayor Vincent Cianci, is one of the m. He is a man of vision and tolerance who understood that remembering and honoring the victims of the Holocaust would be a good lesson for future generations, that hopefully they would learn to practice tolerance and understanding among all people, regardless of race or religion.
Mayor Cianci warmly embraced the idea of erecting a m emo rial for our loved ones who perished in the Holocaust and as a tribute to the survivors of this enormity. Now that this magnificent monument is to be dedicated, we, the survivors, surely are grateful for the mayor's vision and generosity.
The monument's inscription is "Zachor, " which means remember. Yes, remember we must. But what now? More importantly, what of tomorrow? The generation of survivors It is growing old and passing away.
Who will stand up to protect their memory and safeguard their message? The answer must be all of you, Jews and non-Jews alike. In particular, our children and grandchildren of the second and third gene rations, you must have the fire to keep the memory of the Holocaust alive. Do not forget or let the world forget.
This monument must serve as a warning to humanity that freedom is not a birthright; it is a principle for which we must fight every day of our lives. And you, the generations following us, must take up the challenge of fighting anti-Semitism and all prejudice, to prevent a second Holocaust.
[Gastfreund]
Gastfreund, Morris, “Kristallnacht Speech Appeals to the Generations to Come,” Rhode Island Jewish Herald, 52 (November 18, 1993): 3., http://www.rijha.org/wp-content/uploads/voiceandherald/1993/1993-11-18.pdf (accessed April 18, 2024)
Poplow, Lee, “In the beginning: The story of Holocaust education in Rhode Island,” Jewish Rhode Island, October 25, 2018., https://www.jewishrhody.com/stories/in-the-beginning-the-story-of-holocaust-education-in-rhode-island,9296 (accessed April 18, 2024)
Smith, Alison, “Holocaust Memorial Dedicated on Kristallnacht Anniversary,” Rhode Island Jewish Herald, 52 (November 18, 1993): 1., http://www.rijha.org/wp-content/uploads/voiceandherald/1993/1993-11-18.pdf (accessed April 18, 2024)
“Barney Zeitz: About Barney,” Barney Zeitz personal site, https://bzeitz.com/barney.html (accessed April 18, 2024)
“Memorial Garden,” Sandra Bornstein Holocaust Education Center, https://bornsteinholocaustcenter.org/resources-2/memorial-garden/ (accessed April 18, 2024)