Obj. ID: 50466
  Memorials National Holocaust Memorial in Buenos Aires, Argentina, 2016
Memorial Name
The National Monument to the Memory of the Victims of the Jewish Holocaust
[Monumento Nacional de la memoria de Las Víctimas del Holocausto Judío]
Description
The memorial, located in the Plaza de la Shoá (Shoah Plaza), is comprised of a wall of 114 pre-cast concrete parallelepipeds, 39 meters long and 4 meters high. The blocks are stacked in a line in front of a row of trees. The wall appears to be embedded in the railway embankment in from of which it stands. The monument does not command a central position but rather serves as a backdrop to the Plaza de la Shoá (former Paseo de la Infanta).
The wall faces the grassy plaza, where set in the center is a low concrete pedestal on which is a tilted travertine slab on which is a bronze plaque, announcing that this is the Monumento Nacional de la memoria de Las Víctimas del Holocausto Judío (National Monument of the Memory of the Victims of the Jewish Holocaust). Closer to the entrance from Av. del Libertador, is a sign announcing the "Plaza de la Shoah," and a low-mounted map of the plaza and the adjacent park.
The number 114 represents the total number of victims of the attack on the Israeli embassy in Argentina in 1992 and of the attack on the Asociación Mutual Israelita Argentina (AMIA) in 1994. The blocks are stacked unevenly so that some protrude more than others. In a very general way, the arrangement recalls the large stone blocks in Jerusalem's Kotel (the western wall of the Temple base).
The concrete blocks of the wall are imprinted with everyday objects on their faces, including shoes, toys, tools, a fork, eyeglasses, a kitchen apron, a girl's dress, suspenders, a radio, a camcorder, a slide projector, roller skates. headphones, computer keyboards, a camera, an umbrella, books, a scooter, musical instruments, dishes, appliances, a cane, a toy car racetrack, a skateboard, pacifiers, etc. These were made by creating silicone rubber molds of the objects and embedding these in the concrete.
The only historical aspect of the monument is provided by three inscribed black cubes: one gives the name to the monument, another has a Magen David and the third has the year of creation inscribed: "2014", and "5775" (according to the Jewish calendar). The dates of the Holocaust are not provided. Plaques at the end of the wall give the name of the monument, and list government officials, architects, workers, and donors.
Nothing is explained on the monument. There is no history, no facts, no dates, and hardly any reference to the victims or the circumstances of their deaths. There are no names or information about the victims. The inclusion of casts of common 21st century objects that would have been unknown at the time of the Holocaust is confusing.
Several signs surround the plaza, naming it, the memorial, and asking visitors to be respectful. There is night illumination of the monument from the ground level.
Inscriptions
Entrance Sign (Spanish)
Plaza de la Shoá
Translation: Shoah Square
Sign next to the monument (Spanish)
Este es un espacio de memoria y
reflexión por las víctimas del Holocausto.
Cuidémoslo entre todos.
Translation: This is a space for memory and reflection for the victims of the Holocaust. / Let's take care of it.
Plaque on the Memorial (Spanish)
Monumento Nacional
a la memoria
de las Victimas
del Holocausto Judío
Translation: National Monument to the memory of the Victims of the Jewish Holocaust.
Commission plaque (Spanish)
Presidencia de la Nación
Dra. Cristina Fernández de Kirchner
Vicepresidencia de la Nación
Arrigo Boudou
Ministerio de Cultura de la Nación
Teresa Parodi
Secretario de Gestión Cultural
Jorge Espiñeira
Translation: President of the Nation Dr. Cristina Fernández de Kirchner / Vice President of the Nation Arrigo Boudou / Ministry of Culture of the Nation Teresa Parodi / Secretary of Cultural Management Jorge Espiñeira
Creators and Donors Plaque (Spanish)
Realizadores: Gustavo Nielsen, Sebastián Marsiglia, arquitectos.
Equipo: [list of names]
Donantes: [list of names]
Translation: Directors: Gustavo Nielsen, Sebastián Marsiglia, architects. / Team: [list of names] / Donors [list of names]
Plaque at the entrance of the plaza (Spanish)
Monumento Nacional
de la memoria
de Las Víctimas
del Holocausto Judío
Translation: National Monument of the Memory of the Victims of the Jewish Holocaust
Commissioned by
The government of Argentina, with private donations
sub-set tree:
Black granite
Travertine
Bronze
Individual blocks are 90 cms wide and either 60, 90, or 120 cms high.
Pedestal on grassy area is 40 cm deep x 50 cm wide x 60 cm high
Travertine slab is 54 x 75 cms ; bronze plaque 40 x 61 cms
In 1996, the National Congress passed law 24,636 sponsored by deputies Claudio Mendoza, Alfredo Bravo, Federico Storani and Graciela Fernández Meijide, "for the construction of a national monument to the memory of the victims of the Jewish Holocaust". In 2000, in accordance with the new law, the Government ordered the construction of the work "National Monument to the Memory of the Victims of the Holocaust". Due to multiple rejections from different social sectors of the proposed monument locations the law was not fulfilled. Not until 2006 did the Legislature of the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires authorize the present location by Law 2268.
In 2007, the place where the monument is located today was given the name Paseo Marcela Brenda Iglesias, replacing Paseo de la Infanta, in memory of a girl who died from falling off a sculpture incorrectly placed on that site. In 2008, however, the City Legislature approved law 2728, locating the delayed memorial on the site and changing the site name to Plaza de Tribute to the Victims of the Holocaust-Shoá.
In 2009, the international competition for the monument was organized by the Ministry of Culture was held with 70 submissions. The jury consisting of Andrés Duprat (Secretary of Culture of the Presidency of the Nation); Teresa Maffeis (Ministry of Education of the Nation); Jaime Grinberg (University of Buenos Aires); Claudio Avruj (Government of the City of Buenos Aires); Dario Jaraj (DAIA); Yiftah Curiel (Embassy of the State of Israel in Buenos Aires); and Donata Finckenstein (Embassy of the Federal Republic of Germany in Buenos Aires, representing Ambassador Gunter Kniess). Architects Gustavo Nielsen and Sebastián Marsiglia took first prize. At the same time, the prominent Brazilian landscape designer Rosa Kliass voluntarily offered to collaborate with the City offices to enhance the landscape project.
The allocated budget was 4.4 million pesos provided by the Ministry of Culture and the government of Buenos Aires. In 2013 the plaza at a cost of two million pesos and finally in 2014 the monument was begun. Work was completed on February 8, 2015, but the inauguration was delayed due to the murder of Alberto Nisman, the prosecutor of the AMIA case. This caused a rupture in relations between the Jewish community (DAIA and AMIA) the national government, and dedications ceremonies were postponed. Only January 25, 2016, was the monument was finally dedicated with ceremonial lighting of six candles, one for every million Jewish victims. The event was carried out by the Secretariat of Human Rights and Cultural Pluralism of the Nation, within the framework of the International Day of Commemoration in Memory of the Victims of the Holocaust , together with ministers, ambassadors, officials, representatives of the Judiciary, survivors and relatives of the victims. On May 3, 2016, Mauricio Macri, the governor of the city of Buenos Aires, inaugurated Shoá Plaza.
"Argentina dedicates national monument honoring Holocaust victims, rescuers," Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA), January 27, 2016, https://www.jta.org/2016/01/27/global/argentina-dedicates-national-monument-honoring-holocaust-victims-rescuers (accessed April 18, 2024)
Berjman, Sonia, "Demorada Plaza de la Shoá," Diario La Nación, April 24, 2012., https://www.lanacion.com.ar/opinion/miradas/demorada-plaza-de-la-shoa-nid1467585/ (accessed April 18, 2024)
"Ley CABA Nº: 2268 / 2006," Ciudad y Derechos, January 25, 2007, http://www.ciudadyderechos.org.ar/derechosbasicos_l.php?id=0&id2=0&id3=5162 (accessed April 18, 2024)
"Monumento a las víctimas del holocausto judío," Ministerio de Cultura, April 9, 2014, https://web.archive.org/web/20160818035158/http:/www.cultura.gob.ar/noticias/monumento-a-las-victimas-del-holocausto-judio/ (accessed April 18, 2024)
"Monumento Nacional a la Memoria de las Víctimas del Holocausto Judío,"
Wikipedia, https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monumento_Nacional_a_la_Memoria_de_las_Víctimas_del_Holocausto_Judío.
Nielson, Gustavo, "El Monumento Nacional a la Memoria de las Víctimas del Holocausto Judío. La memoria cotidiana" Diario Página 12, November 18, 2012, https://www.pagina12.com.ar/diario/suplementos/radar/9-8382-2012-11-18.html (accessed April 18, 2024)
Nielson, Gustavo and Sebastián Marsiglia, “Monumento Nacional a la Memoria de las Víctimas del Holocausto Judío.” ARQA Argentina, October 13, 2009, https://arqa.com/arquitectura/proyectos/monumento-nacional-a-la-memoria-de-las-victimas-de-holocausto-judio.html (accessed April 18, 2024)
Reinoso, Susana, "Hormigón y objetos rotos para no olvidar a las víctimas del Holocausto," Diario Clarín, April 3, 2015, https://www.clarin.com/cultura/holocausto-memorial-monumento-victimas-judios-gustavo_nielsen_0_r1XKMW5vQe.html (accessed April 18, 2024)
Schachar, Natalie A., "Latin America's first Holocaust monument is delayed, yet again," Times of Israel, June 24, 2012, https://www.timesofisrael.com/in-argentina-construction-of-holocaust-monument-delayed-as-government-looks-for-funds/ (accessed April 18, 2024)